Connect with others who understand.

  •   Learn from expert-reviewed resources
  •   Real advice from people who’ve been there
  •   People who understand what you’re going through
Sign Up Log In
Powered By
Real members of MyCOPDTeam have posted questions and answers that support our community guidelines, and should not be taken as medical advice. Looking for the latest medically reviewed content by doctors and experts? Visit our resource section.
A MyCOPDTeam Member asked a question πŸ’­
Pittsburgh, PA
July 21
 · 
Reactions
A MyCOPDTeam Member

Hello Dennis, Welcome to the group. An interesting question. But the best and quietest and not necessarily going to go hand in hand. Let's face it all the concentrators are loud and noisy. The POC [Portable oxygen concentrator] because it is right there on you. To most people they sound like a refrigerator running. So their mid will dismiss most the noise. I think it is more important to look at the output and efficiency of the units. Along with the ability it increase dosage as our condition worsens.
It is hard to test each of the units and know what is best. But from my research [6 years ago] I chose the Inogen G5 because of the quality, readability, quietness, life of battery, ability to increase dosage, and the lifetime warrantee. I was @ 2l oxygen then, now on 3l. It is hard or was hard for me to get used to the pulse dose form the POC but learned to just breathe and trust the machines dosage.
For me it was the best decision I cold make. It gives 4 hours out away from home and freedom to do things without worrying about running out of oxygen.

Hope that helps you some, I am sure others will have some things to say about the other machines. Have a breathe Ez day........

July 22
A MyCOPDTeam Member

I'm interested in specifics not just the names of manufacturers. Are all three mentioned of equal quality? What are the pros and cons of each?

July 21
MyCOPDTeam

Finding the "best" portable oxygen concentrator (POC) really depends on individual needs, lifestyle, and what a doctor prescribes. That said, there are some well-regarded options worth discussing with a pulmonologist.

One model that comes up often among MyCOPDTeam members is the Inogen One G5, praised for its portability Show Full Answer

Finding the "best" portable oxygen concentrator (POC) really depends on individual needs, lifestyle, and what a doctor prescribes. That said, there are some well-regarded options worth discussing with a pulmonologist.

One model that comes up often among MyCOPDTeam members is the Inogen One G5, praised for its portability and ease of use on the go.

When comparing POCs, here are some key factors to consider:

- Noise level β€” Look for decibel ratings; quieter models are generally under 40 dB
- Battery life β€” Longer battery life means more freedom
- Weight β€” Lighter is easier to carry for extended periods
- Oxygen flow settings β€” Make sure it matches your prescribed flow rate
- FAA approval β€” Important if you plan to fly

Some popular brands to ask a doctor or supplier about include Inogen, Respironics (SimplyGo), and Invacare.

Always confirm with a healthcare provider that any POC matches the prescribed oxygen flow rate. A device that's quiet but doesn't meet oxygen needs isn't the right fit β€” no matter how peaceful the silence! πŸ˜„

July 21

Related Questions

View All
A MyCOPDTeam Member asked a question πŸ’­
St. Paul, MN

A MyCOPDTeam Member asked a question πŸ’­
North Olmsted, OH

A MyCOPDTeam Member asked a question πŸ’­
North Olmsted, OH